|
Guidelines for OMEGA Reviewers
General
The goal of OMEGA review process is to
evaluate the accuracy and significance of the submitted manuscripts and
to provide the authors with constructive and timely feedback.
All submissions are to be reviewed for
overall fit according to the Aims and Scope of the Journal. Please see https://www.journals.elsevier.com/omega/
The Editor-in-Chief first screens all
submissions.
It is OMEGA policy to use a single-blind
review process by at least two referees. (i.e., referees know the names
of the authors but authors do not know the names of the referees). The
primary responsibility of the referees is to review the paper with
respect to correctness and exposition. Referees are free to comment on
whether the article fits well with the journal objectives but the
Editor-In-Chief makes the ultimate decision on that.
OMEGA requests that all referees complete
their reviews within 6 weeks in order to permit prompt feedback to the
authors. Revised papers should be reviewed within 4 weeks.
Items to look for
Here are some items the reviewer should
consider during the review process:
Does this manuscript make a substantial
contribution to the literature?
Is the topic appropriate?
Is the literature review appropriate?
Is the paper intellectually stimulating?
Are the procedures, methods and data analysis appropriate?
Is the paper technically sound?
Should material be omitted or added?
Should material be moved to or from an appendix?
Is the paper clearly written?
Is there a concise abstract?
Is the grammar satisfactory?
Are the references complete?
Is the title appropriate?
Does the paper have applied value?
Referee Report http://www.evise.com/evise/faces/pages/navigation/NavController.jspx?JRNL_ACR=OMEGA
(you will need to login EVISE as a reviewer)
The referee report may contain two parts.
|
·
|
The first
part is to the Editor to be shared with the authors.
|
|
·
|
The second
part is to the Editor only and will include candid recommendations and
a summary judgment; this will not be shared with the authors.
|
In the first part
of your report please include:
Summary – include a
short summary of the paper.
Major comments – list all
changes you would like to see in the paper.
Minor comments – typos, length
reduction, indicate whether you wish to see/no need to see the revised
paper
Recommendation – Accept; minor
revisions; major revisions; reject. Include the reasons for your
recommendation
Please submit your report via EVISE. You may
also upload a .doc or .pdf type files of your report.
The Editor-In-Chief wishes to
gratefully acknowledge all those listed who have generously given of
their time to referee the paper submitted to OMEGA.
All members of the Editorial Advisory Board are expected to review
papers, thus are not listed in the above list.
Acknowledgement to referees
(From January 1, 2003 to September 12, 2003) click
here
Acknowledgement to referees
(From September 13, 2003 to September 24, 2004) click
here
Acknowledgement to referees
(From September 25, 2004 to July 26, 2005) click
here
Acknowledgement to referees
(From July 27, 2005 to May 4, 2006) click
here
Acknowledgement to referees
(From May 5, 2006 to March 15, 2007) click
here
Acknowledgement to referees
(From March 16, 2007 to March 31, 2008) click
here
Acknowledgement to referees
(From April 1, 2008 to July 24, 2009) click
here
Acknowledgement to referees
(From July 25, 2009 to May 23, 2010) click
here
Acknowledgement to referees
(From May 24, 2010 to May 3, 2011) click
here
Acknowledgement to referees
(From May 4, 2011 to July 8, 2012) click
here
Acknowledgement to referees
(From July 9, 2012 to May 1, 2013) click
here
Acknowledgement to referees
(From May 2, 2013 to July 13, 2014) click
here
Acknowledgement to referees
(From July 14, 2014 to September 1, 2015) click
here
Acknowledgement to referees
(From September 2, 2015 to November 1, 2016) click
here
Acknowledgement to referees
(From November 1, 2016 to September 30, 2017) click
here Acknowledgement to referees
(From October 1, 2017 to November 30, 2018) click
here Acknowledgement to referees
(From December 1, 2018 to September 30, 2019) click
here Acknowledgement to referees
(From October 1, 2019 to September 30, 2020) click
here Acknowledgement to referees
(From October 1, 2020 to Nov 22, 2021) click
here Acknowledgement to referees
(From Nov 23, 2021 to Sep 13, 2022) click
here Acknowledgement to referees
(From Sep 14, 2022 to Aug 27, 2023) click
here Acknowledgement to referees
(From Aug 28, 2023 to Dec 2, 2024) click
here Acknowledgement to referees
(From Dec 3, 2024 to XXX, 2025) click
here
Best
Reviewer Certificate for 2010
|
Prof. Necmi K
Avkiran
The University
of Queensland
Prof. Ismail Bakal
Middle East Technical
University
Mehmet Candas
University of
Texas at Austin
Prof. Yao Chen
University of
Massachusetts at Lowell
Prof. Juan Du
University of
Science and Technology of China
Prof. Marina
A. Epelman
University of
Michigan
Prof. Hirofumi
Fukuyama
Fukuoka
University
Prof. Jackie
Griffin
Georgia
Institute of Technology
Dr. Qinglong Gou
University of Science and
Technology of China
|
Dr. Florian Jaehn
Universität Siegen
Prof. Laura Kornish
University of
Colorado at Boulder
Prof. Bertrand M.T. Lin
National Chiao Tung University
Prof. Jeng-Jong Lin
Vanung University
Dr Chris Lo
The Hong Kong
Polytechnic University
Prof. Louis Luangkesorn
University of
Pittsburgh
Prof. Jeffrey
Schaller
Eastern
Connecticut State University
Prof. Stephan Wagner
Swiss Federal
Institute of Technology
Dr. Renqian
Zhang
Beihang University
|
Best
Reviewer Certificate for 2011
|
Chien-Ming Chen
Nanyang
Business School
Arun Chockalingam
Purdue
University
Hepu Deng
RMIT
University Melbourne
Andrew L.
Johnson
Texas
A&M
Sigrid Knust
University of Osnabrueck
Susan X. Li
Adelphi
University
Nan Liu
Columbia
University
Hamid Mamani
University of
Washington
Ranga Muhandiramge
Monash University
|
Sophie Parragh
University of
Vienna
Ruben Ruiz
Universidad Politcnica de Valencia
Wenjing Shen
Drexel
University
Malgorzata
Sterna
Poznan
University of Technology
Doug
Thomas
Penn State University
Yu
(Amy) Xia
Northeastern
University
Hao Zhang
USC
Qinghua
Zhu
Dalian
University of Technology
|
Best
Reviewer Certificate for 2012
|
Prof. Jaap Bos
Maastricht
University
Dr. Ozgun Caliskan
Demirag
Penn State Erie
Prof. Luis C.
Dias
Universidade de Coimbra
Prof.
Stanislaw Gawiejnowicz
Adam
Mickiewicz University
Prof. Michael C. Georgiadis
Aristotle University of Thessaloniki
Prof. Abhijit
Gosavi
Missouri University of Science and
Technology
Prof. Janis Grabis
Riga
Technological University
|
Prof. Mohamad Y Jaber
Ryerson University
Dr. Dominik Kress
University of Siegen
Dr. Ivana Ljubic,
University of Vienna
University of Vienna
Prof. Ole Bent
Olesen
University of
Southern Denmark
Ying Rong
Shanghai Jiao Tong University
Prof. Ming-Miin Yu
College of
Maritime Science and Management
Dr. Yong Zha
University of
Science and Technology of China
|
Best
Reviewer Certificate for 2013
|
Deniz Aksen
Koç University
Jun He, Ph.D.
University of Michigan-Dearborn
Sameer
Kumar
University
of St. Thomas
Yongjun Li
University of
Science & Technology of China
Zongmin Li
Sichuan
University
Shiang-Tai Liu
Vanung University
Zhixin (Jason) Liu
University of
Michigan-Dearborn
|
Jenny Nossack
University of
Siegen
Umit Saglam
Drexel
University
Yan Tu
Sichuan
University
Rudolf Vetschera
University of
Vienna
Don Warsing
North Carolina State University
Wann-Ming Wey
National
Taipei University
Luis
Zuluaga
Lehigh University
|
Best
Reviewer Certificate for 2014
|
Claudia Archetti
University
of Brescia
Eva Barrena
HEC
Montreal
Ana Camanho
Universidade do Porto
Hirofumi
Fukuyama
Fukuoka
University
Yi Liao
Southwestern
University of Finance and Economics
Stefan Minner
TUM School
of Management
|
Maite Peña-Alcaraz
Massachusetts
Institute of Technology
Francisco
Ruiz-Aliseda
Ecole Polytechnique
Dvir Shabtay
Ben-Gurion
University of the Negev
Paolo Tubertini
Università di Bologna
Zeshui Xu
Tsinghua
University
|
Best
Reviewer Certificate for 2015 Prof.
Oben Ceryan
Drexel
University
Dr.
Abdullah Konak
Penn
State Berks
Prof.
Wen-Min Lu
National
Defense University
Dr.
Yazemin Merzifonluoglu
Middle
East Technical University Northern Cyprus Campus
Prof. Chuljin Park
Hanyang University, Industrial
Engineering
Professor Biresh K. Sahoo
Xavier
University
Prof. Qiong Wang
University of Illinois at
Urbana-Champaign
Prof. Wenhui Zhao
Shanghai
Jiao Tong University |
Best
Reviewer Certificate for 2016
|
Professor Alireza Amirteimoori
Islamic Azad University
Prof. Metmet S Atlug
George Washington University
Professor Juan Aparicio
University Miguel Hernandez of Elche
Dr. Jason A.D. Atkin
University of Nottingham
Professor José M Cordero
Universidad de Extremadura
Prof. Mohammad Firouz
University of Alabama
Prof. Nick Freeman
University of Houston, Houston, TX, USA
Professor Marc Jegers
Free University of Brussels | Dr. Yue Jin
Nokia
Prof. Thomas Kalinowski
University of Newcastle
Professor Timo Kuosmanen
Aalto University School of Business
Dr. Jannik Matuschke
University of Technology Berlin
Dr. Esther Mohr
University of Mannheim
Dr. Michael Poss
LIRMM
Dr. Kabir Rustogi
University of Greenwich
Professor
Xiaoyang Zhou
Shaanxi Normal University
|
Best
Reviewer Certificate for 2017
|
Qingxian An
Central South University
Olga Battaia
ISAE-SUPAERO
Valentina Cacchiani
University of Bologna
Ozgun Caliskan Demirag
Penn State Erie
Song
Han
Renmin University of
China
Sin C. Ho
The University of Hong
Kong
Milosz Kadzinski
Poznan University of
Technology
Dincer Konur
Missouri University of
Science and Technology
|
John D Lamb
University of Aberdeen
Sebastian Lozano
University of Seville
Stefan Minner
Technical University of
Munich
Alena Otto
University of Siegen
Mahmut Parlar
McMaster University
Fabio Sgarbossa
University of Padova
Shilu Tong
The Chinese
University of Hong Kong
Aida Valls
Universitat Rovira i
Virgili
|
Best
Reviewer Certificate for 2018
|
Michelle Alvarado
University of Florida
Gerardo Berbeglia
University of Melbourne
Girish B.S.
Indian Institute of Space Science and Technology
Chrisof Defryn
Maastricht University
Florian Jaehn
Helmut Schmidt University
David Kaufman
University of Michigan-Dearborn
Shiang-Tai liu
Vanung University
Brian Lunday
Airforce Institute of Technology
Mohammad Marufuzzaman
Mississippi State University
|
David Novak
University of Vermont
Anyan Qi
University of Texas Dallas
Roberto Rossi
University of Edinburgh
Maximilian Schiffer
Aachen University
Rudolf Vetschera
University of Vienna
Shengbin Wang
North Carolina A&T State University
Zelong Yi
Shenzhen University
Ming-Miin Yu
National Taiwan Ocean University
|
Best
Reviewer Certificate for 2019
|
Alessandro Agnetis
Università di Siena
Isil Alev
Boston College
Valentina Cacchiani
University of Bologna
Ozgun Caliskan Demirag
Penn State Behrend University
Leopoldo Eduardo Cárdenas-Barrón
Tecnologico de Monterrey
Michael Doumpos
Technical University of Crete
Jan Fabian Ehmke
Otto-von-Guericke University Magdeburg
Lu Gan
Sichuan Agriculture University
Bogdan Grechuk
University of Leicester
Milosz Kadzinski Poznan University of Technology
Dincer Konur
Texas State University
Eric (Zhaolin) Li
The University of Sydney
Yang Li
Drexel University
|
Qi Lin
Beihang University
Sebastian Lozano
University of Seville
Karthik Murali
Oregon State University
Konstantin Pavlikov
University of Southern Denmark
Antonio Peyrache
The University of Queensland
Xiangtong Qi
Hong Kong University of Science and Technology
Yaqin Sun
Drexel University
Yong Zha
University of Science and Technology of China
Jianqiang Zhang
Jiangsu Normal University
Ming Zhao
Hong Kong Polytechnic University
Ming Zhao
University of Houston
Yuyun Zhong
Drexel University
Jose L. Zofio
Erasmus University
|
| |
Best
Reviewer Certificate for 2020 |
Kerem Akartunali
University of Strathclyde
Tolga Aydinliyim
Baruch College, The City University of New
York
Yiwen Bian
Shanghai University
Jens Brunner
Augsburg University
Ozgun Caliskan
Penn State Behrend University
Salvatore Corrente
University of Catania
Neil Geismar
Texas A&M University
Mansik Hur
California State University, Bakersfield
Kenneth J Klassen
Brock University
Alex Kuiper
University of Amsterdam
Anne-Laure Ladier
Université de Lyon
Martin Lariviere
Northwestern University
|
Shiang-Tai Liu
Vanung University
Sebastian Lozano
Portal Universidad de Sevilla
Broos Maenhout
Ghent University
Karthik Murali
Oregon State university
Julie Paquette
University of Montreal
Mehdi Toloo
Technical University of Ostrava
Christina Requejo
University of Aveiro
Jafar Rezaei
Delft University of Technology
Abhishek Roy
Temple University
Xin Wang
Hong Kong University of Science and Technology
Ming Miin Yu
National Taiwan Ocean University
|
Best
Reviewer Certificate for 2021 |
M.
Serkan Akturk
Clemson
University
Abbas Attarwala
University of Waterloo
Bert M. Balk
Erasmus University Rotterdam
Marco Antonio Boschetti
University of Bologna
Matteo Brunelli
University of Trento
Ana Camanho
Universidade
do Porto
Jasmine
Chang
New
Jersey Institute of Technology
Ada Che
Northwestern Polytechnic
University
Zhijie Dong
Texas State University
Andreas Ernst
Monash University
Christoph
Glock
Technical
University of Darmstadt
Mansik
Hur
California
State University, Bakersfield
Bassam Hussein
Norwegian University of
Science and Technology
Moutaz Khouja
University of North Carolina
|
Martin
Lariviere
Northwestern
University
Huchang Liao
Sichuan University
Brian Lunday
Air Force Institute of Technology
Frank
Meisel
Kiel
University
Christopher
Parmeter
University
of Miami
Jafar Rezaei
Delft University of
Technology
Christos Roumpos
National Technical University
of Athens
Jeffrey Schaller
Eastern Connecticut State
University
Justus Arne Schwarz
University Regensburg
Pieter Smet
Katholieke Universiteit
Jian-Jun
Wang
Dalian
University of Technology
Ke Wang
Beijing Institute of Technology
Zhe Zhang
Nanjing University of Science
and Technology
Weiwei Zhu
Nanjing University of Posts and Telecommunications
|
Best
Reviewer Certificate for 2022 |
Alireza Amirteimoori
Islamic
Azad University
Manish Bansal
Virginia Tech University
Udo Buscher
Technische Universität
Dresden
Joseph Chow
New York University
Laszlo Csato
Corvinus University of Budapest
Erdi Dasdemir
Hacettepe University
Fang Fang
California State University,
Los Angeles
Cheng Fan Hou
University of Science and Technology of China
Don Galagedera
Monash University
Joseph Geunes
Texas A&M University
|
Luiz Flavio
Autran Monteiro Gomes
Faculdades Ibmec Rj Brazil
Jafar Hussain
Nanchang
Institute of Technology
Zhongping Li
Anhui University
Miao Song
The Hong Kong Polytechnic University
Menelaos Tasiou
University of Portsmouth
Losif Viktoratos
Aristotle University
Jiao Wang
University of Electronic Science and
Technology of China
Xinfang Wang
Georgia Southern University
Guang Xiao
The Hong Kong Polytechnic University
Yuanguang Zhong
South China University of Technology
|
Best Reviewer Certificate for 2023
Jasmine
Chang
New Jersey
institute of Technology
Weiwei Chen
Rutgers
university
Ya Chen
Hefei
University of Technology
Junfei Chu
Central
South University
Laszlo Csato
Corvinus University of Budapest
Enrico De Giorgi
University of St. Gallen
Xin Geng
University
of Miami
Mengzhuo Guo
Sichuan University
Magdalena
Kapelko
Wroclaw
University of Economics and Business
Gulsah Karakaya
Middle East Technical University
Wei Li
Southwestern
University of Finance and Economics
|
Xingyu Li
University
of Michigan
Catherine
Lorenz
University
of Passau
Brian
Lunday
Air Force
Institute of Technology
Mahmood
Mehdiloo
University
of Mohaghegh Ardabili
Shenle Pan
Paris Mines Tech
Grammatoula
Papaioannou
Loughborough
University
Roberto
Rossi
University
of Edinburgh
Peter
Schütz
Norwegian
University of Science and Technology
Jiayan Xu
Sun Yat-Sen
University
Yuli Zhang
Beijing
Institute of Technology
Yuanguang
zhong
South China
University of Technology
|
Best
Reviewer Certificate for 2024 |
Xinyan Cao
Northern Illinois University
Oben Ceryan
City, University of London
Laszlo Csato
Corvinus
University
Nesreen El-Rayes
Georgia State University
Raymond Lei Fan
Grand Valley State University
Fang Fang
California State University, Los Angeles
Nickolas Freeman
University of Alabama
Amir Hosseini
University of Passau
Jan-Erik Justkowiak
University of Siegen
Musen Li
Shanghai University
Yi Li
Xi'an Jiaotong University
Zongmin Li
Sichuan University
Decui Liang
University of
Electronic Science and Technology of China
|
Shiang-Tai Liu
Vanung University
Sebastian Lozano
University of Seville
Inês Marques
Universidade de Lisboa
Grammatoula Papaioannou
Loughborough University
Johannes Schuenemann
University of Göttingen
Radovan Somplak
Brno University of Technology
Minghe Sun
University of Texas San Antonio
Ming-Lang Tseng
Asia University
Liao Xiuwu
Xian Jiaotong
University
Xiaokai Wu
Wilfrid Laurier University
Yuli Zhang
Beijing Institute of Technology
Qiuhong Zhao
Beihang University
Fuqin Zhou
New Jersey Institute of Technology
|
| 